Monday, October 31, 2011

Greyhound Breeders Defend Broken Legs at Texas Track

Last week, GREY2K USA released a report on greyhound injuries at Gulf Greyhound Park. According to state records, 1,351 greyhound injuries have been reported at the track since 2008, including dogs that suffered broken legs, paralysis, and a fractured skull.

When we released this report, I knew it was only a matter of time before dog racing promoters tried to rationalize the high injury rate at Gulf. That is why I was not surprised when National Greyhound Association member Robert Gross minimized these serious injuries on Facebook last Saturday. He started his defense by falsely claiming that most of the injuries reported at Gulf were minor:
"1,351 injuries in 43 months - most of them minor."
This is simply not true. In fact, the most commonly reported injury was a broken leg. Further, as the Houston Chronicle noted only 32% of all reported greyhound injuries at Gulf involved sprains or strained or pulled muscles.

The next defense Gross used is priceless. He actually claimed that the Gulf injuries aren't significant, because 180,000 "individual Greyhounds" raced at the track during the period covered in our report:
"22,575 races involving 180,600 individual Greyhounds. Seems to me that Greyhound racing is an extremely safe sport."
Of course, this is completely false. To reach his ridiculous figure, Gross is counting the same greyhounds over and over again dozens of times, and pretending that each "start" represents a different dog. In reality, a few thousand greyhounds likely raced at Gulf during this period.

Finally, Gross ended his rationalization with a snide remark about my adopted greyhound Zoe, who recently cut her foot while on a walk:
"Considering that Carey Theil's only greyhound was rushed to the hospital recently due to a serious laceration while on a walk. Looks like the injury rate for his Greyhound is 100%."
I realize that greyhound breeders have become experts at rationalizing and denying the cruelty of dog racing. Nonetheless, I am surprised by the naivety of this argument. To be clear, when a greyhound suffers an injury while on a walk around the neighborhood, that is a sad accident.

By contrast, the experience of greyhounds in the racing industry is quite different. Greyhound breeders "produce" large numbers of dogs. They ship them off to racetracks, where the dogs live in warehouse style kennels in rows of stacked cages. The dogs race against each other so that gamblers can use them as numbers to bet on. Every year, greyhounds suffer thousands of injuries, and the breeders know full well that many of the dogs they send to race will die on the track. To them, this is simply the price of doing business. Like greyhound trainer John O'Donnell said in 2008, to them broken legs are "no big deal."

The death of greyhounds like Carla and Patches, two sisters who died at Gulf, are not accidents. Instead, they are the entirely predictable result of an industry that is cruel and inhumane.

8 comments:

  1. A new low - - criticizing an adopted greyhound's injury received while on a leisurely walk.

    However, trying to convince people of fuzzy math by misrepresenting the number of dogs as the number of "starts" is old, old news.

    What is not fuzzy math, though, are the declining greyhound racing attendance and revenue figures.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For the people in dog racing and similar "industries," animals are nothing more than pieces of equipment.
    I've tried to understand people who feel this way, but have found it impossible to grasp that level of non-compassion.
    They know the general public has a level of compassion for animals so their only choice is to twist and spin with false propaganda.

    Tom Grady

    ReplyDelete
  3. How low can they get. Probably makes them feel better to ridicule you and your little accident with Zoe. Shame on him!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. At least in this business dogs just break their legs, can you imagine bullfighting? Geez!
    I'm in no way, shape or form defending what these idiots do to greyhounds.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am a new leadout at the Sarasota Kennel Club. I have questions on how these dogs are taken care of. I witnessed a dog today that likely broke their leg during a race. I have yet to hear the prognosis. I fear the animal will be put down because the owners won't want to pay to hospitalize it. What is the likelihood of this happening? I refuse to be associated with a business/organization that can quickly discard "damaged goods".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Please e-mail any details you have about this injury to info@grey2kusa.org. We will be happy to look into it.

      Delete
    2. It is with a heavy burden that I have to say this: Flying Demi Lovato #2 dog in Race #13 was put to sleep at request of owner Keith Williams due to a broken leg that she received during a race Nov.15, 2013. I know this isn't the first, but I will help those who want to make this the last incident.

      Delete